Section 1: What Is Complex Parenting Litigation?
What is Complex Parenting Litigation?
Complex parenting litigation refers to court proceedings in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia which involve competing applications, usually made by parents, seeking the court’s assistance with determining who should have the power to make decisions relating to a child or children, where the children live and who the children spend time with. The complexity often comes about due to factors such as allegations of sexual or physical abuse, parental incarceration, parental mental ill health or substance abuse issues, and children with significant physical or mental ill health. You can read more about the Federal Circuit and Family Court and how they manage parenting litigation here: https://www.fcfcoa.gov.au/fl/children/overview.
How is Complex Parenting Litigation different from a regular parenting dispute?
Regular parenting disputes are often negotiated and resolved within therapeutic settings such as mediation or family therapy, where parties can remain child-focused and work together for the best interests of their children; in fact, only about 3% of separated parents use court to resolve parenting matters. On the other hand, complex parenting litigation requires a Judge to determine the matter because risk or other factors often render it impossible for the parties to negotiate and reach an outcome together.
What issues and circumstances cause a parenting matter to become complex?
Parenting matters typically become complex when there are allegations of sexual abuse or serious physical abuse, or when a child or parent has a mental or physical health condition that puts the child at risk. Data from the Federal Circuit and Family Court shows that 40% of parenting matters before the court allege mental ill health has caused or poses a risk to a child and 54% allege child abuse.
What does “the best interests of the child” mean under Australian law, and how does a court determine what that looks like in practice?
The best interests of the child is the paramount consideration the court must adopt when making orders about children. In practice, the court is required to consider the following when determining what arrangements reflect a particular child’s best interests:
- What arrangements will promote the safety of the child and those who care for the child.
- What views the child has expressed about their care arrangements and those who care for them.
- What developmental, psychological, emotional and cultural needs the particular child has.
- The capacity each person who is seeking to care for the child has to provide for the child’s needs.
- The benefit to the child of having a relationship with their parents or other carers.
- Any other circumstance that is relevant to the child in question.
The Family Law Act was significantly amended in May 2024. What changed, and what does that mean for parents in dispute today?
In 2024, the Family Law Act changed how the courts considered the best interests of children by including specific reference to promoting safety. This shifted the lens to place the consideration of safety of arrangements above all other aspects. Further, the Act was amended to remove the “equal shared parental responsibility” which previously assumed that all children benefit from both parents making long-term decisions, save in some cases. This presumption no longer exists, and instead decision-making relating to long-term aspects impacting a child is considered on a case-by-case basis, in terms of how joint decision-making will promote the safety of the child in question.
What are the most common and consequential mistakes parents make before obtaining legal advice?
When parents act from a position that lacks education or advice, they often act from a place of fear. They might believe that children must spend equal time with each parent as a starting point or that they are compelled to facilitate a time with a parent even when there are serious allegations of risk. This can mean parents agree to arrangements that do not promote the safety of their children due to a lack of legal advice and an understanding of how risks can be mitigated and safety promoted.
Section 2: Interstate Parenting – When Parents Live in Different States

How does the family court approach parenting arrangements when parents live in different Australian states?
The Family Law Act 1975 is federal legislation which means that it applies across all Australian states and territories. Therefore, even where parents live in different states, the same law applies to their parenting situation. Research indicates that around 10 – 12% of children in separated families live 500 km or more from their non-resident parent (https://aifs.gov.au/media/news/family-law-reforms-put-childrens-best-interests-front-and-centre). It is therefore not unusual for the court to consider orders for children when one parent lives many hours away, sometimes in another state.
Where this is a factor, the court will need to consider what arrangements will reflect the best interests of that particular child. This means the court will consider the proposed time-sharing arrangements and how they will affect the child’s travel between the parents, whether the arrangements will require the child to miss school or other activities, the child’s age, and any other relevant circumstances.
If one parent wants to move to another state with the children and the other parent objects, what is the legal process for resolving that dispute?
Moving a child away from one parent to a location that makes time more difficult requires the consent of the other parent or a court order. Failing to obtain these can result in an urgent court application such as a “recovery” order by the other parent who opposes the move. If a parent wants to relocate with the children to another state, they should first seek consent either by lawyer negotiation or mediation.
If agreement cannot be reached in this way, then an application can be made to the court for an order to relocate. Here the court will then hear the competing evidence and decide whether the relocation reflects the best interests of the children and what time the other parent should have if the move occurs.
What factors does the court weigh when deciding whether to permit or refuse an interstate relocation with children?
Relocation matters are very difficult matters for Judges to decide. Often these matters involve loving, engaged parents who would otherwise not be before the court, and both provide the children with stable, happy homes. In these cases, the court must still place the best interests of the children as the paramount consideration, but the exercise of this can be extremely complex.
The key takeaway in these matters from case law is that parties seeking to relocate do not need to demonstrate compelling reasons for the move, although in most cases they can and do. Further relocations are likely more successful where the children are older and have a well-established relationship with both parents; younger children, however, may find it difficult to develop a relationship where they move away and have less time and cannot enjoy the benefits of modern communication methods like video calls.
What are the practical and emotional consequences for children in long-distance parenting arrangements, and how should those be addressed in a parenting order?
Children who move away after a relocation is permitted will need to adjust to a new home, school, friends, and a new timetable for spending time with their other parent. The court is required to ensure arrangements reflect the best interests of the child and will consider orders that facilitate the ongoing relationship with the other parent such as:
- Spending more time during school holiday periods.
- Spending one or two weekends during school terms.
- Allowing time to occur in the child’s new home state at any time the other parent chooses to travel there.
- Making orders for phone, video and written communication between the children and other parent.
Orders such as this can result in children maintaining a strong, loving connection with both parents despite the relocation.
Section 3: Magellan Matters – Serious Abuse Allegations in the Family Court

What is the Magellan List, and what kinds of cases does it deal with?
The Magellan List is a specialist court list in Division 1 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, managed by a multidisciplinary team of Court Child Experts, Judges, and other Registrars. The list deals with the most vulnerable children where allegations of sexual abuse and serious physical abuse exist.
How does a parenting matter end up in the Magellan List, and what does the process look like once it is listed there?
Parenting matters transferred into the Magellan List will generally involve notifications or allegations of child sexual abuse, serious physical abuse of a child, fresh allegations of historical abuse that had not been raised before or where a parent or step-parent poses a risk of sexual abuse or they are alleged, charged or convicted of having engaged in the production, possession or distribution of child exploitation material.
What is a Notice of Child Abuse, Family Violence or Risk, and what happens after one is filed?
Notice of Child Abuse, Family Violence or Risk is a mandatory form that is completed and filed with the court when commencing proceedings relating to parenting matters. The form is intended to ensure the court is made aware of allegations of abuse or risk as early as possible so the court can report such matters to child welfare authorities and, if necessary, list the matter in a specialised list.
What role does the Independent Children’s Lawyer play in a Magellan matter, and how does their involvement affect the proceedings?
An Independent Children’s Lawyer is a lawyer appointed by the court to assist the court determine what arrangements reflect the best interests of the particular child. Although they will speak with the children, they do not act for the children and instead form their own view on what orders should be made. They will often arrange expert evidence from family report writers and assist self-represented parties to negotiate.
Section 4: Relocation – Moving Away With the Children
What is relocation in the context of family law, and why are these matters considered among the most difficult parenting cases to resolve?
Relocation refers to an application by one parent to move the children of the relationship to a location that makes time with the other parent significantly more difficult. If, for example, a child lived a 30-minute drive from one parent’s home and was spending time regularly with that parent during the week and on weekends, a move that placed the child 90 minutes away could be considered a relocation if that additional time made the previous arrangements unworkable.
Moving, however, to the next suburb, where the child can still spend the same usual time with the other parent and continue attending the same school, would not be regarded as a relocation and would not necessarily require the other parent’s consent.
Relocations, however, tend to be interstate or overseas moves, not necessarily just a few hours away, although such moves could fall within “relocation”.
What must a parent do legally before relocating interstate with their children, and what are the consequences of moving without permission?
Changing a child’s living arrangements in a way that makes time with the other parent significantly more difficult should occur only with the other parent’s consent; if consent is not obtained, then by order of the court.
Consent to relocate can be obtained through negotiations with a lawyer or in mediation, where parties can reality-test the proposed move, travel expectations, and the time the children will actually spend with the other parent.
Often, through mediation, the reality of the proposed relocation becomes less frightening, and the parent not moving can see that the proposed time, in some cases, can result in more time with their children than they enjoyed previously.
What factors does the court weigh when deciding whether to permit or refuse a proposed relocation with children?
The paramount consideration is the best interests of the particular children. This will require the court to consider the children’s views, their emotional, physical, and cultural needs, the children’s relationship with each parent, and how the move will impact that relationship. These matters are often far from easy to determine, particularly when both parents have provided consistent, loving homes for the children post-separation.
When can a parent take their children overseas, and what permission is required to do so lawfully?
International travel should occur only with the consent of both parents or where a court order permits it. If a parenting order exists relating to a child and a parent takes that child overseas without the express written consent of the other parent, they could be committing an offence under the Family Law Act.
If no parenting order exists and a parent wants to travel internationally with a child, they should still seek the other parent’s consent. Failing to do so could result in issues when departing Australia or arriving in the foreign country. It could also lead to court proceedings under International Child Abduction legislation.

What is the criminal consequence of removing a child from Australia without consent or a court order?
Under the Family Law Act, if a parenting order exists and consent from the other parent or a court order permitting the travel is not obtained, the travelling parent could be found guilty of an offence that carries a maximum penalty of 3 years’ imprisonment.
What is the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, and how does it operate in practice when a child is wrongfully taken overseas?
The Hague Convention refers to an international treaty that mandates the return of children from signatory countries if the children have been taken to that country without consent or a proper court order. Many countries are signatories to the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, including Australia.
There are, however, some countries that are not signatories, and if a child is taken to a non-signatory country, securing the return of the child will depend on accessing local courts in that country and may not result in the child returning.
What is the AFP Family Law Watchlist, and in what circumstances would it be used to prevent a child from being removed from Australia?
In order to protect children from being unlawfully removed from Australia, there is a Family Law Watch List maintained by the Australian Federal Police. Children named in this list cannot exit/leave the country when attempting to pass through border control.
To be included on this list, a parent can apply to the Federal Circuit and Family Court for the necessary order and must provide evidence of the risk of departure. This would include evidence that the child has a passport in their possession and that the other parent is at risk of removing the child from Australia.
Section 5: Neurodiversity in Parenting Proceedings
How does a child’s neurodiversity affect the way parenting arrangements need to be structured?
All parenting arrangements need to place the best interests of the child as the paramount consideration. This means, in practice, that each child will have differing needs and requirements, and that parenting orders and arrangements should reflect these.
When a child is neurodiverse, their needs present a unique profile that must be considered and adapted to. Parenting arrangements will need to consider continuity across homes and the child’s ability to travel with consistent bedding or toys for sensory purposes.
The parents need to be across explicit needs for neurodiverse children when it comes to transitions and supports required. Typically, parents can determine what will best support their neurodiverse child across two homes by working with the child’s treating specialists.
What do courts need to understand about neurodiverse children that is often overlooked?
Courts can only work with the evidence they are presented with. When a child has additional needs, it is essential that evidence of those needs is presented clearly, along with recommended supports and interventions.
Litigation involving neurodiverse children requires careful consideration and explanation of the child in question. It should never be assumed that courts will understand a child’s needs if those needs are not expressed with clarity and supported by evidence from treating specialists.
What expert evidence is required in parenting matters involving a neurodiverse child, and how does it influence the court’s decision?
Neurodiverse children will usually have a core team of treating professionals, which can include the paediatrician, occupational therapist, speech pathologist, psychologist, play therapist, and other allied health professionals. Evidence from all of these can assist in building a comprehensive picture of the child in question and what that child requires to have their best interests met.
How does the family court assess the parenting capacity of a parent who is themselves neurodiverse?
It is not unusual at all for parents before the court to be diagnosed as neurodiverse, and for some they are undiagnosed. When this is a factor, the court will need to understand how that neurodiversity impacts the child and the care that the parent can provide.
This does not need to be viewed negatively; neurodiverse parents may offer a neurodiverse child a sense of identity and better understand the challenges a child faces. The intention here is to understand each parent’s capacity so that arrangements can best reflect the needs of the child in question.
Section 6: Drug and Alcohol Risks in Parenting Matters
How does the family court assess the impact of a parent’s drug or alcohol use on parenting arrangements, and what is the threshold for it to affect the outcome of a matter?
The existence of drug or alcohol dependency alone does not prevent a child from forming a meaningful and loving relationship with a parent where such a relationship can be managed in a safe way for the child.
- When a court needs to consider these matters, relevant factors will include the age of the child in question, as younger children require greater supervision and care and rely more on their parents for that care. This contrasts with an older child, who requires different levels of care.
- Another factor will be the type of drug or alcohol, the level of use or dependence, and whether the parent is engaged with treatment services.
The court will ultimately need to balance the parenting arrangements to ensure the child’s safety, guided by the best interests of the child. This could range from no time, to supervised time, to time with certain restraints.
What types of drug and alcohol testing can the family court order?
The court regularly orders drug and alcohol testing to determine whether parents are using certain substances, and sometimes to determine the level of use. Tests can include urine, blood, and hair, and can determine drug use many months ago and whether long-term alcohol abuse appears to be a factor.
These tests are conducted by government-approved testing facilities and provide clear evidence of substance issues.
What parenting orders can the court make where substance use is established or strongly suspected, and how do those orders typically evolve?
If substance use or abuse has been found or is suspected, we typically see courts making orders for ongoing testing, restraints on use before or during time with children, and orders for engagement with treatment. As circumstances change over time, these arrangements can be revisited.
Learn more here: How to Change Final Parenting Orders.
What are the legal consequences for a parent who refuses to comply with a court-ordered drug or alcohol test?
If the court makes an order for drug or alcohol testing and a parent does not comply with that order, the court has several options relating to enforcement of the order. This can include a fine or bond for failing to comply with the order. The court can also draw a negative inference from failing to comply with the testing order, meaning it can infer that the results were likely to be positive, which is why the parent refused to complete the test.
What should a parent do if they have genuine concerns about the other parent’s sobriety at the time of a scheduled changeover?
If changeover and time are occurring pursuant to court orders and the other parent’s sobriety is in dispute, the orders might already provide for how such circumstances are to be managed.
If the orders do not provide for this, a parent can suspend time when they have a reasonable excuse, which requires the parent to form a reasonable belief that breaching the orders was necessary to protect the child’s health and safety for a limited period.
Breaching an order should be the last resort and never done without serious consideration.
Section 7: Family Violence and Risk to Children in the Family Court
How does Australian family law define family violence?
The Family Law Act defines family violence as violent, threatening, or other behaviour that coerces a family member or causes them to be fearful. Examples of this include physical assaults like hitting and pushing, sexual assault or abuse, stalking, derogatory taunts, damaging property, injuring a pet or animal, financial abuse, and limiting access to family, friends, or culture.
In what circumstances is a child considered to have been exposed to family violence?
A child will have been exposed to family violence if they see, hear, or are otherwise exposed to family violence. This can include seeing a parent upset after an incident, cleaning up after property damage, and being present when police or other services respond to an incident.
How do domestic violence protection orders interact with family court parenting orders? What happens when the two conflict?
If a person is the victim of family violence or requires protection from family violence, they can often obtain an order through their local or Magistrates’ Court for a Family Violence Intervention Order (in Victoria). These orders can be sought by police or the victim and can offer immediate protection from all forms of family violence. When such an order is being sought, the Magistrate will enquire as to whether there are any family law orders and, if so, consider how these will interact with a protection order.
In many cases, however, family law orders do not yet exist, and this is the first step in separation following a family violence incident. When this occurs, the protection order will usually include an exception allowing the parties to attend mediation, negotiate through lawyers, or do anything permitted by a Family Law Act order or agreement. This enables the protection order to operate in addition to the Family Law order.
What obligations does the family court have when family violence is raised in parenting proceedings?
If family violence is raised, the court must consider what interim orders should be made to collect evidence about the allegations and what orders will protect the children and parties. This can include appointing an independent children’s lawyer in parenting cases to represent the child’s interests.
What is the Family Violence Cross-Examination Scheme, why was it introduced, and how does it operate in practice?
The Family Violence Cross-Examination Scheme was introduced to protect victims of family violence from being directly cross-examined at trials by their alleged abuser. In practice, as a matter progresses towards trial or a final hearing, the court will make an order for legal aid in the relevant state to fund a lawyer to prepare for and conduct the cross-examination of a victim at trial.
This applies when the alleged perpetrator is appearing on their own behalf at trial and where they have been charged or convicted of a family violence offence, or where there are final cross-family violence protection orders in place. When the funding is provided, a lawyer will then appear at the trial and conduct the cross-examination for the self-represented party.
Section 8: Coercive Control in Parenting Matters
What is coercive control, and how does Australian family law recognise it as a form of family violence?
Coercive control as a term is not defined in the Family Law Act, but it is widely recognised as being a pattern of abusive and controlling behaviour towards another person. Coercive control can be subtle and easier to hide than other forms of family violence.
What are the most common patterns of coercive controlling behaviour that arise in parenting proceedings (and how do they affect the children in those families)?
The most common patterns of coercive controlling behaviour can include tracking a person’s whereabouts, controlling all aspects of their spending, and criticising and degrading the other person regularly. The ANU undertook a study on the effects of coercive control on children when exposed to a parent perpetrating it on the other parent or the children. They found children can be profoundly affected even if they are not the direct targets. The report identified impacts on children’s social, emotional, and physical development.
What is a Harmful Proceedings Order, when can it be sought, and what problem does it address in the context of coercive control?
A Harmful Proceedings Order is an order made by the court that prohibits a party from starting proceedings without leave of the court. Such an order can be made where the court is satisfied that the other party or child would suffer harm, such as psychological harm, major mental distress, or financial harm, if the proceedings were allowed.
When considering such an order, the court will look at the history of proceedings between the parties, including in other courts, and the cumulative impact of these proceedings.
What are the signs that a former partner is using the family court system as a tool of ongoing coercion and control, and what legal remedies are available?
Signs of using the court system as a tool of coercion or control can include the issuing of multiple proceedings in different courts that appear to lack merit or proper standing. In a family law context this could include one party issuing multiple interim applications in the Family Court whilst also engaging in litigation in Magistrates Court around Family Violence Intervention Orders. It can also be seen where a party issues subpoenas seeking information that is not relevant to proceedings such as medical records. Legislation and updates to practice rules works to limit this behaviour by creating obstacles to filing court proceedings, for example there are limits on subpoenas and where a person is not represented by a lawyer their ability to seek certain information is limited. Where the court makes a Harmful Proceedings Order this will prohibit the other party from filing applications without approval of the court.
Section 9: When a Child Refuses to Spend Time With a Parent
What is the legal and practical significance of a child refusing to spend time with a parent, and how does the court begin to assess that situation?
A child refusing to spend time with a parent is a significant issue that needs to be addressed urgently and in a child-focused way. The first question always needs to be – Why? Why does the child refuse to spend time with a parent? Once the ‘why’ is understood, steps can be taken to address it and determine whether it is safe for the child to resume spending time with the parent.
If a child refused to go to school or attend the dentist (both of which usually reflect a child’s best interests), parents would not simply accept the child’s position without investigation. Instead, they would ask “why?” and once the issue is determined, they would work with the child to get back to a place where the child is happy to go to school or see the dentist.
When a child refuses to spend time with a parent and the parties are in litigation before the court, the court will need to determine what time should occur and how, considering the child’s best interests and what arrangements will promote the child’s safety. This often means that the child and parents will meet with a court-appointed expert, such as a psychologist or social worker. The expert will speak with the child to determine their views and prepare a report recommending whether visitation time should recommence and, if so, how.
How much weight does the family court give to a child’s expressed wishes about parenting arrangements, and what factors influence how seriously those wishes are taken?
The views expressed by a child are put to the court via a court-appointed expert. The court will typically place more weight on those views when the child is older; for example, a 14 year old stating that they do not wish to spend time with a parent will often attract more weight than a 6 year old saying the same thing. The court will also consider the child’s maturity and take into account any special needs when deciding how much weight to give to any views expressed.
Where a parent is found to be deliberately undermining the child’s relationship with the other parent, what orders can the court make in response?
If a court finds that one parent is actively undermining the child’s relationship with the other parent, it can make various orders to deal with this. These orders range from parenting courses to family therapy, and in extreme cases a court can order that the child should move and live with the other parent if that parent can show that they will facilitate a relationship.
What is reunification therapy, and when does the court order it, and what does that process involve for the family?
Reunification therapy in Australia does not refer to a particular type of therapy, but rather is a term adopted by some psychologists and social workers who offer therapeutic assistance to children and parents to repair or reestablish their relationship. In cases before the Family Court where the relationship between a child and parent has completely broken down, some parents will seek orders for therapy to assist in repairing the relationship. The therapy may be called family therapy, family counselling or sometimes reunification therapy.
If such an order is sought, the court will require evidence from an expert on the specific type of therapy being proposed and its potential impact on the children involved. Only after reviewing this information will the court decide if participating in such therapy serves the children’s best interests and promotes their safety.
If a parent stops facilitating court-ordered time because a child refuses to attend, are they in breach of their parenting orders? What are the legal consequences?
If there are orders for a child to spend time with a parent and the child refuses to attend, the withholding parent may be found to have breached a court order, which is a serious matter.
A child refusing to attend time alone will not typically be a reasonable excuse for failing to comply with orders and facilitate time. This brings us back to the “why?” question. If a child refuses to spend time in line with a court order, the parent should set about determining why the child is expressing this view and then seek legal advice on the appropriate next steps, which might include an urgent application to court to set aside the time orders.

Section 10: Supervised Parenting Time
What is supervised parenting time, in what circumstances does the family court order it, and how should it be understood by the parent it is ordered against?
Supervised time refers to a parent’s time with the children being monitored by a third party, usually to ensure the children’s safety. Supervised time is often ordered when children are vulnerable to risk, and another person’s supervision can alleviate that risk.
Risk to the child can take many forms; sometimes it is because the child is very young and the parent is very inexperienced and cannot meet their needs without support.
Sometimes it is because a parent has active drug and alcohol issues, and a supervisor can ensure the children spend time without exposure to drug or alcohol use. Other times, supervision can be ordered when the child does not yet have a relationship with their parent. During the initial introduction period, a supervisor can help the parent and child establish their relationship. If a parent is required to attend supervised time, they should see it as a great opportunity to provide the court with independent evidence of their time with the child, rather than viewing supervision as a negative.
Typically when a court orders supervision of time and a professional supervision service is used the professional supervisor will prepare reports detailing how time has progressed. Such reports are then filed with the court, and this evidence assists the court and others to understand how time has progressed and what supports might be required to progress time further.
What are the different forms of supervised parenting?
Supervision can be either professional supervision from an agency that provides supervisors, or it can sometimes be a person or family member close to the child who is willing to take on this role.
Professional supervisors are often social workers or child protection workers and can assist with changeover and location or settings for supervised time. Family members typically do not have training and must provide the court with an undertaking that they understand their role and will act to ensure the child’s safety.
What does a supervised parenting session actually involve, and what conduct on the part of the parent can result in a session being terminated?
Supervised sessions typically take place in a public location such as a playground or play centre. These locations usually allow about 1.5 to 2 hours of supervised time and help the child view the time positively.
The supervisor usually facilitates the changeover by meeting the child and the other parent at the start of the time and returning the child at the end. During supervised time, the supervisor is usually required to be with the child at all times, within hearing and sight of the parent. This ensures that all interactions are observed and that the child remains safe.
The supervised parenting session can be terminated for various reasons, including a parent being drug- or alcohol affected, the parent becoming aggressive or distressed, the child becoming distressed, or the child becoming ill.
What does a parent need to demonstrate to progress from supervised to unsupervised parenting time?
In order to progress from supervised to non-supervised time, the parent must show the court that such time reflects the child’s best interests and promotes the child’s safety. If this can be shown, then time will progress from supervised to unsupervised. Often, the evidence supporting a move away from supervision will be supervision reports, which detail how time has progressed, how the child has engaged with the parent, and how the parent has navigated that time.
Are there circumstances in which supervised parenting time should be opposed entirely?
Supervised time is often opposed only when it is proposed on an ongoing basis. Courts often consider that ongoing supervision does not reflect a child’s best interests. Supervision may not be necessary where children are older, have a secure relationship with the other parent, and supervision has been proposed without proper justification.
Section 11: Children’s Evidence and Participation in Family Court Proceedings
In what circumstances does a child give evidence in family court proceedings, and what protections exist if that occurs?
A (sworn) affidavit primarily provides evidence in the Family Court, and at trial any person who filed an affidavit can be cross-examined on their sworn evidence. Children are not permitted to swear affidavits under the Family Law Act without a court order allowing it, and this is extremely rare.
If a court did allow a child to swear an affidavit, special leave would then be required for the child to be cross-examined. In practice, despite the Act allowing for it, children do not swear affidavits or attend for cross-examination, save for the rarest of matters.
How does the family court hear from children about their experiences and views without requiring them to give evidence in court?
To ensure the court is aware of children’s views and wishes, children meet with a court-appointed expert. These experts are usually psychologists or social workers, and they spend time with the child to talk about their life, what makes them happy and what they would change if they could.
These meetings are intended to be safe, calm environments where children can speak without either parent present. Once the expert has sufficient information, they will prepare a report (called a family report) for the court. The report will detail the child’s views and wishes, along with the expert’s recommendation on what arrangements would best reflect that child’s interests.
The family report is filed with the court on an affidavit, and the report writer can then be cross-examined on the report if required.

What is a family report, how is it prepared, and what weight does the court place on the views a child expresses during that process?
The family report process typically involves the court expert meeting with the children separately, as well as meeting with each parent individually. The expert may also observe the children interacting with each parent. Before preparing the report, the expert will review all relevant court documents and may consult with other professionals involved with the family, such as psychologists or doctors.
Once the expert has gathered enough information, they will prepare the family report and file it with the court as an affidavit. While the court is not obligated to follow the recommendations made in the expert report, these reports carry significant weight and can be subject to cross-examination.
How has the role of the Independent Children’s Lawyer changed under the 2023 amendments to the Family Law Act?
Since May 2024, ICLs (Independent Children’s Lawyers) must meet personally with children and give them an opportunity to express any views they might have about the proceedings. These meetings are not required for children under 5, where the child does not wish to meet with the ICL, or where such a meeting could expose the child to risk or adversely affect their well-being.
Once the child expresses their view to the ICL, the ICL must then advise the court of it. Previously, this was not the case, and the ICL had discretion to decide whether to put the child’s views to the court or not.



